Independent comparisons. We may earn from shop links. More info

Best carnivorous plant kit on these three listings

Updated: 21 October 2026

You still want one of the three kits, and you want the listing that hides the least. Best carnivorous plant kit on this page means the least unclear row in the [carnivorous plants comparison](/hub/houseplants/carnivorous-plants), not the best carnivorous plant in Britain. Gift Republic is about £12.99 (3.5 from 469), Funtime about £6.99 (2.9 from 721), and Seed Pantry about £15.00 with no review line. A rooted flytrap was about £13 to £15 in October 2026, so leaving the set is a real option. Peter F. compared the amazon.co.uk listings and did not germinate anything. A qualifying purchase can earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

You still want one of the three kits, and you want the listing that hides the least.

Our top picks

Gift Republic Gift Republic GR200010

Best overall

Gift Republic Gift Republic GR200010
6.3/10about £12.99
View offer
Funtime Gifts Funtime Gifts tin

Alternative

Funtime Gifts Funtime Gifts tin
5.6/10about £6.99
View offer
Seed Pantry Seed Pantry seed kit

Best value

Seed Pantry Seed Pantry seed kit
3.2/10about £15.00
View offer
On this page
  1. 1.What each listing promises
  2. 2.What the review files actually repeat
  3. 3.Who should buy which kit
  4. 4.Who should leave the set

What each listing promises

Funtime's bullets say each tin includes both sundew and Venus flytrap seed, and that you just add water and sun. The tin is the pot, at 6.5 x 9 x 6.5 cm, with no drainage mentioned. Seed Pantry says Venus flytrap or trumpet pitcher seed, two rice-husk pots, peat-free compost and a grow guide. You are not told you receive both. Its care line is the only one that says full sun and a cooler place in winter dormancy. Gift Republic's plant-type field says venus fly. The bullets do not name a species, pots or compost. The size line, 12.6 x 9.7 x 16.7 cm, is the carton. The sunlight field says shadow. The brand page lists coconut-husk pots and calls the kit a novelty whose seed can die. If the amazon.co.uk listing does not state the pots, do not assume they are in the parcel. How you water whatever arrives is on carnivorous plant care.

What the review files actually repeat

Across 721 reviews at 2.9, the tin's repeated story is nothing after weeks or months, or a seedling that was not a flytrap: cactus, grass, a herb, or a thin stem with a red flower. Seeds are one or two specks in a sachet. Reviewers say the tin cannot drain. The instructions they found include a fridge step of about two to three weeks, which the bullet does not mention. Gift Republic's 469 reviews at 3.5 still are not a guarantee. The common report is several weeks in the fridge, one to three seeds, mould, and no germination. A minority say something grew, or that the unopened kit was a fair gift. Missing husks and the wrong Grow It box also appear. Seed Pantry has no review line. An empty file is not a quiet success. If the kit is for next week, read seeds or a plant.
Gift Republic Gift Republic GR200010

Testsieger

Gift Republic Gift Republic GR200010
6.3/10about £12.99
View offer

Who should buy which kit

Buy Seed Pantry only if you want the stated pots, the peat-free compost and the winter sentence, and you will sow whichever species arrives. At about £15 it is the best value in this set because the other listings leave pots as a second purchase. It is not the top pick. There is no review sample, so the badge is not evidence that the seed germinates. The top pick, if you insist on a reviewed kit, is the Gift Republic box: 3.5 from 469, and the failure theme is often nothing rather than often the wrong plant. Open the box against the listing you paid for. Check the live price.

Who should leave the set

Do not buy the Funtime tin for a Venus flytrap. About £6.99 is the lowest price, and 721 reviews support the theme: no plant, or not that plant, and a container that holds water. A stocking filler you are happy to throw away is the only brief that fits. Everyone else should leave the set and buy a plant already in leaf if they need traps this month.

Common questions

Which of these three kits is the better one?
Gift Republic is the top pick if you want a reviewed kit and you accept that many buyers see no germination after a fridge step. Seed Pantry states more of the parts you need and has no reviews, so it is a contents pick, not a proven one. Funtime is the one to leave if the label must match the plant.
Is the £6.99 tin good value?
The price is low and the outcome in 721 reviews is poor. Buyers report empty compost, a hidden speck of seed, seedlings that are not flytraps, and a tin with no drainage. That is a cheap object, not a cheap plant. Spend the same effort on a rooted plant if the flytrap is the point.
Why does Seed Pantry cost more with no reviews?
The listing states two rice-husk pots, peat-free compost and a grow guide, which the other listings do not itemise, and the shelf price was about £15.00. There is no star line, so the extra money buys stated parts, not a published germination record. The species line still says.
Does the Gift Republic box include pots?
The amazon.co.uk listing used here does not say. One review says you still need to buy pots, and others mention missing coconut husks. The brand's own page lists coconut-husk pots and then disclaims germination. Order from the listing in front of you, and do not fill the gap with the brand page.
Can I trust a 3.5-star kit with 469 reviews?
You can trust the theme. Hundreds of UK reviews cluster on a long cold wait, very few seeds and no sprout, with a minority of successes and gift praise. A 3.5 average means the kit is not universally hated. It does not mean your packet will germinate.
What if the amazon price is no longer £12.99?
Use the price on the page when you order. The comparison listing showed about £12.99 and 3.5 from 469. A later search snippet showed about £17.54 and 3.6 from 464. Either figure can be wrong by the time you click. The review theme is the stable part.

Related pages

Carnivorous plants buying guide

Carnivorous plants

Carnivorous plant care: rainwater, light and a rest

Venus fly trap seeds or a plant when the date matters

Venus fly trap care in the UK, including a winter rest

Sources

Public UK sources named below. amazon.co.uk prices, stars and review counts on these three listings are the figures used for this comparison. Page updated 21 October 2026.

  1. RHS carnivorous plants growing guide (retrieved 21 October 2026)
  2. RHS carnivorous plants overview (retrieved 21 October 2026)
  3. RHS Venus flytrap (retrieved 21 October 2026)
  4. GOV.UK CITES imports and exports (retrieved 21 October 2026)
  5. Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 (retrieved 21 October 2026)
  6. NNSS purple pitcher plant (retrieved 21 October 2026)
  7. Defra horticultural peat announcement (retrieved 21 October 2026)
  8. Consumer Rights Act 2015 (retrieved 21 October 2026)