Independent comparisons. We may earn from shop links. More info

Fibreglass or hickory club hammer

Updated: 23 October 2026

You have seen a wooden hammer head work loose, and the listing offers fibreglass, hickory, or a single word that just says wood. A fibreglass or hickory club hammer is a choice about the shaft, not about how hard the blow needs to be. Fibreglass is the handle you buy when you will not maintain a wedge. Hickory is the handle you buy when you will check the head every time and stop the moment it moves. The product table is the [Lump hammer comparison](/hub/hand-tools/lump-hammer). Prices are the amazon.co.uk snapshot of 22 October 2026. Products Compared did not lab-test handles. A qualifying purchase through our links can earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.

You have seen a wooden hammer head work loose, and the listing offers fibreglass, hickory, or a single word that just says wood.

Our top picks

OX OX Trade 2.5 lb club hammer

Best overall

OX OX Trade 2.5 lb club hammer
8.6/10about £12.00
View offer
Faithfull Faithfull FAIFG4 4 lb club hammer

Best value

Faithfull Faithfull FAIFG4 4 lb club hammer
8.4/10about £8.99
View offer
Faithfull Faithfull 2.5 lb hickory club hammer

Alternative

Faithfull Faithfull 2.5 lb hickory club hammer
5.9/10about £8.15
View offer
On this page
  1. 1.What actually differs
  2. 2.Fibreglass in this set
  3. 3.The hickory Faithfull
  4. 4.Which to buy

What actually differs

The head is a steel block on a short shaft. What changes is how that joint lives in a shed. Hickory can take some sting out of a blow, and BuildWiz says the same wood can shrink until the head loosens. Fibreglass is the usual homeowner choice because it is not expected to dry out. A shock-absorbing bullet is the seller’s sentence, not a measurement. Grip the head and try to twist it. Movement or a click means you stop. HSE’s INDG229 says a loose or split shaft comes out of use.

Fibreglass in this set

Most kept listings are fibreglass or a fibreglass core: the OX 2.5 lb at £12.00, the Faithfull FAIFG4 4 lb at £8.99, plus Milwaukee, WORKPRO, Bargain Hound, and MUKCHAP. The OX and the 4 lb Faithfull have 3,349 and 1,493 reviews. Neither pasted set describes the head coming off. The OX item-weight row of 133 g against a 1.1 kg title is a catalogue fault, not a handle fault. The 4 lb Faithfull does not claim BS 876. One UK review of the WORKPRO says the hammer broke within three hours, against 4.6 from 123 reviews.
OX OX Trade 2.5 lb club hammer

Testsieger

OX OX Trade 2.5 lb club hammer
8.6/10about £12.00
View offer

The hickory Faithfull

The wooden example is Faithfull FAIHC212C, ASIN B0001IWU2C, at £8.15. The title is 2.5 lb / 1.14 kg. The bullets say a 220 mm hickory handle and that the hammer is manufactured in accordance with BS 876. That is the only such claim among the nine, and it is not a certificate. The star line is 4.7 from 85 reviews. The item-weight row says 572 g, which is not the 1.14 kg title, and the head-material row says hickory wood. The head is not hickory. One UK reviewer returned the hammer three times because the head was loose. Buy it if you will twist-test the head.

Which to buy

Choose fibreglass if you will not maintain a wedge: the OX at 2.5 lb when you need to place blows, or the Faithfull FAIFG4 at 4 lb for a short heavy job. Choose the hickory Faithfull only if you will check the head every time and stop when it moves. JAPCHET sells two 1 kg hammers with wood handles for £13.99 and names no species, so you cannot call it hickory. ASelected’s material row says stainless steel and the bullets describe a rubber grip, at £9.99, with a 1,700 g title that matches the 1.69 kg item weight.

Common questions

Will a fibreglass head come loose?
It can. It is less likely to loosen because the handle dried out, which is the usual wooden failure. The OX and the Faithfull 4 lb, with 3,349 and 1,493 reviews, do not have a pasted theme of heads coming off. One WORKPRO review still says that hammer broke within three hours. Check the joint when the hammer is new and after a hard session. A cracked fibreglass neck is scrap, not a wedge you knock back in.
How do I know a hickory head is loose?
Hold the head and turn the handle. Any rock, click, or gap at the eye means it is loose. A wedge sitting proud, or a handle that has shrunk away from the steel, is the sign you can see before it shifts. The Faithfull reviewer who sent three hammers back had already found that movement. If you feel it, you stop. You do not seat it with a tap on the floor and then swing at a chisel.
Does BS 876 mean the head cannot loosen?
No. The hickory Faithfull bullets say the hammer is manufactured in accordance with BS 876. That is a claim, not a certificate, and it sits beside a 572 g item-weight row and a three-return loose-head review. The standard covers hand hammers. It does not freeze a wooden joint against a dry shed. The 4 lb Faithfull does not mention BS 876 at all.
Which Faithfull is hickory and which is fibreglass?
FAIHC212C is the hickory 2.5 lb, at £8.15, with a 220 mm handle stated, a BS 876 claim, and 85 reviews. FAIFG4 is the fibreglass 4 lb, at £8.99, with no BS 876 line and 1,493 reviews. The model codes are the reliable split. Faithfull club hammer on its own is how people order the heavy head while wanting the wooden one. Check the handle line and the title weight before you buy.
What is the JAPCHET handle if it only says wood?
Unknown. The listing says wood and names no species, so you cannot assume hickory or a matching spare. You get two 1 kg hammers, 28.7 cm long, for £13.99, with one review from Ireland. Treat it as an unspecified wooden handle, check both heads, and keep it as a light pair for pegs rather than the hickory option in this comparison.
Can I keep using a hammer with a moving head?
No. INDG229’s rule is to reject a loose shaft. A head that shifts can leave the handle on the next blow. That applies at home as well as on a site. Return it if it is new, or scrap it if the joint has failed. Do not tape the neck, and do not soak a loose hickory head so it swells for one more brick. The brick can wait.

Related pages

2.5 lb or 4 lb club hammer

Club hammer buying guide

How to use a club hammer

Lump hammer

Best lump hammer for bolster work, 4 lb, or hickory

Sources

Sources from the research digest, last checked on 22 October 2026.

  1. BS 876:1995, specification for hand hammers (retrieved 22.10.2026)
  2. InterDIY, hammers buyer's guide (retrieved 22.10.2026)
  3. Screwfix, hammer buying guide (retrieved 22.10.2026)
  4. BuildWiz, club hammer (retrieved 22.10.2026)
  5. HSE, INDG229 Using work equipment safely (retrieved 22.10.2026)
  6. HSE, using the right type of PPE (retrieved 22.10.2026)
  7. PUWER 1998, regulation 4 (retrieved 22.10.2026)
  8. Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 9 (retrieved 22.10.2026)
  9. DIY Doctor, using a brick bolster (retrieved 22.10.2026)
  10. CMT, club hammers with a hickory handle (retrieved 22.10.2026)
  11. Sealey, hammer instructions (retrieved 22.10.2026)