Independent comparisons. We may earn from shop links. More info

Best charcoal barbecue UK

Updated: 23 October 2026

You want a short answer from twelve charcoal listings, not another magazine that tested a Kamado Joe you are not buying. This page is the best charcoal barbecue UK shortlist inside these amazon.co.uk listings: which rows have a lid, a grate claim you can defend, and a review sample that matches the price. The Products Compared editorial team wrote it on 21 October 2026 from listing figures checked on 19 October 2026 and public UK sources. Nothing here was cooked in a lab. Shelf prices move on the [barbecue comparison](/hub/grills-and-barbecues/barbecue). A qualifying purchase through our links can earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.

You want a short answer from twelve charcoal listings, not another magazine that tested a Kamado Joe you are not buying.

Our top picks

Weber Weber Compact Kettle 47 cm

Best overall

Weber Weber Compact Kettle 47 cm
8.9/10about £49.49
View offer
Big Smokey Big Smokey barrel

Alternative

Big Smokey Big Smokey barrel
8.4/10about £67.99
View offer
HOMION HOMION kettle 43.5 cm

Best value

HOMION HOMION kettle 43.5 cm
7.9/10about £28.99
View offer
On this page
  1. 1.What a top pick can mean in these listings
  2. 2.The three Weber kettles
  3. 3.Barrels and smokers at this money
  4. 4.Who should skip which row

What a top pick can mean in these listings

Best here means three checks, in order. First, a lid and vents so you can cook closed. Second, a grate figure from the bullets, not a square-centimetre field that repeats the diameter. Third, an amazon.co.uk rating sample large enough that six five-star clicks cannot outvote hundreds of owners. BBC Good Food’s 2026 charcoal table and The Guardian’s June 2026 BBQ piece test other models at other prices. They are useful press context. They are not scores for these ASINs. The largest rating sample with a lid is the Weber Compact Kettle 47 cm at £49.49, 4.5 from 377 ratings. That volume beats every other row. A KEYO 29 inch spit barrel also shows 4.5, but from only six ratings at £133.99. Treat that average as almost empty. Decision order before any shortlist sits on the charcoal barbecue buying guide.

The three Weber kettles

The Compact, model 1502054 on the listing, is the top pick for most patio cooks who want a 47 cm kettle under £50 with a thick review base. Bullets claim porcelain enamel, dampers, a stand with wheels and 1,548 cm² for four to six people. They do not claim a lid thermometer. One UK review expected a gauge from the description and did not find it. Assembly is called slightly fiddly, then the cook is praised. Weber UK sold the same model number at £94.99 including VAT in the same window, and the Amazon listing prints warranty text “2.” State both. Do not merge them into one promise. The Original 47 cm at £111.24, 4.5 from 65 ratings, keeps the same 1,548 cm² bullet and adds a built-in lid thermometer and One-Touch ash cleaning. Pay that step when the gauge and the ash system matter more than the Compact’s shelf price. The Premium 57 cm at £239.00, 4.5 from 117, claims 2,342 cm² for six to eight people and a thermometer.
Weber Weber Compact Kettle 47 cm

Testsieger

Weber Weber Compact Kettle 47 cm
8.9/10about £49.49
View offer

Barrels and smokers at this money

If the job is a long grate for about six adults, the barrel case is Big Smokey at £67.99, 4.4 from 173 ratings, with a claimed 71 × 35.3 cm main grill and a warming rack. Reviewers describe labelled parts and a solid feel. Lump charcoal can fall through the coal grate, so briquettes are the review workaround, and the push handle sits on the wheeled leg. The HOMION oil drum at £63.94, 4.2 from 67, is cheaper on the shelf but carries wrong-part and support complaints. Shape trade-offs sit on kettle or barrel barbecue. Among the hooded smokers, House Of Home XL at £99.99 and 4.5 from 71 is the stronger file against Campfire XL at the same price and 3.2 from 82. Kendane at £79.98 includes a verified UK review that the vent and racks melted after one cook. Stop using any grill that softens in the fire.

Who should skip which row

Skip the Amig if you need closed-lid heat. Skip both KEYO carts if the UK cook record is thin; non-UK reviews also report cracked viewing glass on the window model. Skip Campfire if you will not fight missing legs, and Kendane if a melt report is enough to walk away. Skip the Premium if you only cook for two. Do not import a bestseller rank from a neighbouring Compact ASIN. Model 1221004 carries a different star count. Do not paste that figure onto B0FTZN1YYZ.

Common questions

Is the cheapest grill the best value?
Not if it has no lid. The Amig at £17.89 is the lowest shelf price and an open box. Best value in practice sits with a lid kettle or a barrel that still has a usable review sample, such as the Compact, the HOMION kettle or Big Smokey.
What do you give up if you buy the Compact instead of the Original 47 cm?
You give up the built-in lid thermometer and the One-Touch ash line the Original bullets claim. You keep the same 1,548 cm² grate claim and a much larger rating sample at a lower price.
When is the £239 Premium the one to pay for?
When you need the 57 cm Premium’s larger grate claim and will host beyond what a 47 cm kettle covers. It is not the value play against the Compact at £49.49.
Can a UK magazine test stand in for these ASINs?
No. Good Food and The Guardian tested other models at other prices. Use them for criteria, not as scores for these listings.
Do Weber’s own prices match the Amazon shelf price?
Not in this window. Weber UK listed the Compact at £94.99 including VAT while amazon.co.uk showed £49.49 for this ASIN. Prices move; read the live page before you buy.

Related pages

Barbecue for a small space

How to light a barbecue

Barbecue

Charcoal barbecue buying guide: lid, vents and grate

Kettle BBQ vs barrel barbecue: a dome or long grate

Sources

Public UK sources used for this comparison. Listing prices, stars and review counts are the amazon.co.uk figures for these ASINs. Retrieved 22 October 2026.

  1. GOV.UK: smoke control area rules (retrieved 22 October 2026)
  2. GOV.UK: smoke control enforcement in England (retrieved 22 October 2026)
  3. GOV.UK: fire safety outdoors (retrieved 22 October 2026)
  4. Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 9 (retrieved 22 October 2026)
  5. BSI: BS EN 1860-1:2024 solid-fuel barbecues (retrieved 22 October 2026)
  6. Weber UK: how to control charcoal temperature (retrieved 22 October 2026)
  7. Weber UK: charcoal kettle prices (retrieved 22 October 2026)
  8. The Guardian, 11 June 2026: best BBQs and grills tested (retrieved 22 October 2026)