The best spades, compared.
Top pick: KKTECH Digging Spade, one-piece, plastic handle Best value: Roughneck ROU68224 digging spade – Best value: about £15.59 for a treaded digging spade with a stated length, after flexing-head reviews are already deducted. Updated October 2026.
A garden spade is a flat-bladed hand tool for cutting turf, turning soil and digging holes. UK listings sell it as a digging spade or a smaller border spade. A shovel scoops loose material and cuts undisturbed ground poorly, so a title that says spade is not the blade. Quality shows at the socket and the steel: a solid-forged or long riveted joint takes leverage better than a thin head, and a shaft you can use without stooping matters as much as the metal. Type, socket, metal and tread are set out in the [spade buying guide](/hub/digging-tools/spade/sub/spade-buying-guide). You use it to cut turf, turn soil and dig holes. In UK shops the two everyday sizes are a digging spade and a smaller border spade. A digging spade has the wider flat blade for beds, shrub holes and lawn edges. A border spade is the same idea with a narrower blade, so it fits between plants and moves less soil per cut. Pointed and transplanting spades exist in UK tool tests.
A garden spade is a flat-bladed hand tool for cutting turf, turning soil and digging holes. UK listings sell it as a digging spade or a smaller border spade.
22 products checked · 58 hrs invested · +18,600 readers
Swipe for more
1-2 of 6
Personal buying guide
Question 1 of 2
What are you digging?
The KKTECH GSPADE-01 is listed at £15.99 with 4.7 from 108 amazon.co.uk reviews, the smallest count in this set. Bullets claim a rust-resistant one-piece carbon-fibre body and a plastic handle, with a height of 102 cm and a width of 18 cm. The specification block says the material is carbon steel and plastic, the blade is carbon steel, and the dimensions are 50 × 180 × 1020 mm. Both statements are on the same listing, so you cannot treat this as a carbon-fibre spade and drop the steel line. Reviews that were read praise a sharp edge, lawn edging, and the price, and some buyers say it is not as light as they hoped. There is no usable listed weight. A 4.7 on 108 reviews moves more easily than the same stars on a file of more than a thousand.
Pros
Cons
Best for: You want a cheap spade for lawn edging and you have read both the carbon-fibre bullets and the carbon-steel specification.
Less suitable: You are choosing because of the 4.7, or you need one stated material and a weight you can compare.
Specifications
Common questions
Is this a digging spade or a border spade?
The listing classifies it as a digging spade.
What is the blade and handle made of?
The specification says carbon steel. The bullets also say a carbon-fibre body. Handle: plastic.
Does it have foot treads, and how long is it?
Foot treads are not stated. The bullets list a height of 102 cm. A usable listed weight is not stated.
The Spear & Jackson 4450DS is a traditional stainless digging spade at £24.20, with 4.6 from 1,426 amazon.co.uk reviews. In the raw capture it ranks 347 in Garden and first in Gardening Spades. The head is mirror-polished stainless on a double-riveted hardwood wishbone, listed at 102 cm. Reviewers praise the look, the wooden shaft, and comfort over a long session. The recurring failure is that wooden shaft snapping where it enters the socket, sometimes after light use and sometimes after a few years. Foot treads are not stated in the bullets. The listed weight of 181 g is not a weight you can treat as the tool.
Pros
Cons
Best for: You want a stainless head that wipes clean, and you will not lever the wooden shaft against roots or a stump.
Less suitable: You are breaking stony ground, or you expect the shaft to take the same leverage as a steel handle.
Specifications
Common questions
Is this a digging spade or a border spade?
The listing classifies it as a digging spade.
What is the blade and handle made of?
Blade: stainless steel. Handle: wood.
Does it have foot treads, and how long is it?
Foot treads are not stated in the bullets. Listed length: 102 cm. A usable listed weight is not stated.
The JCB JCBDS01 is a solid-forged carbon steel digging spade listed at 98 cm and 2.4 kg, with integrated foot treads and a powder-coated head. Across 121 amazon.co.uk reviews it sits at 4.6. Reviewers who praise it talk about cutting roots and lawns, and about a joint that does not flex. The same file calls it too heavy for light garden work. At least one buyer reports the blade bent on first use, so the forged claim is not a guarantee against a bad head. At £29.99 it is the dearest spade in this set. The listing does not say whether it folds.
Pros
Cons
Best for: You are turning heavy ground or cutting roots, and you can lift 2.4 kg through a session.
Less suitable: You want a light border tool, or you only dig short spells in soil that is already loose.
Specifications
Common questions
Is this a digging spade or a border spade?
The listing classifies it as a digging spade.
What is the blade and handle made of?
Blade: carbon steel. Handle: metal.
Does it have foot treads, and how long is it?
Foot treads: yes, integrated. Listed length: 98 cm. Listed weight: 2.4 kg.
The Spear & Jackson 4190NB Elements is a heat-treated carbon digging spade at £20.79, rated 4.5 from 892 amazon.co.uk reviews. Reviewers use it on clay and for ordinary digging at this price. The listing weight is 2.08 kg, the model name says treaded, and a reviewer mentions steps on the blade shoulder. Criticisms include a thin blade for heavy work, a handle that snapped, and one weld that failed before the buyer received a replacement. One reviewer found the blade only a little larger than their border spade, so the word digging in the title is not a measured width. The listed dimensions of 10.25 metres are not a length you can stand in the garden and use. The listing cites a Grow Your Own 2022 Great British Growing Award, which is the seller's claim, not a test repeated here.
Pros
Cons
Best for: You want a mid-price carbon digging spade for clay and ordinary beds, and you will not use the shaft as a lever.
Less suitable: You need a thick forged head for rubble, or a blade you have measured as clearly wider than a border spade.
Specifications
Common questions
Is this a digging spade or a border spade?
The listing classifies it as a digging spade.
What is the blade and handle made of?
Blade: carbon steel. Handle: a polypropylene D-grip on an ash shaft.
Does it have foot treads, and how long is it?
The model name says treaded, and a reviewer mentions steps on the blade shoulder. A usable listed length is not stated. Listed weight: 2.08 kg.
The Draper 88792 is the border spade in this set, epoxy-coated carbon steel at £14.86, with 4.5 from 634 amazon.co.uk reviews. The listing length is 92.5 cm and the listing weight is 998 g, which one reviewer disputes after a scale showed 4.4 lb against a 2.2 lb claim. Reviewers use it between plants and in clay that contains stones. Other reviews say the face bent in dense mud within minutes, and that a turned lip catches on pots. The bullets misspell border as boarder and also say forged fencing spade, while the title is a border spade. It moves less soil per cut than a digging spade, which is the point of the narrower blade until the ground is too dense for this head.
Pros
Cons
Best for: You are planting between existing plants or working a tight bed, and the soil is not dense rubble.
Less suitable: You are turning a new bed, edging a lawn in volume, or digging stony clay with this as your only spade.
Specifications
Common questions
Is this a digging spade or a border spade?
The listing classifies it as a border spade.
What is the blade and handle made of?
Blade: carbon steel. Handle: plastic-coated, with a steel core.
Does it have foot treads, and how long is it?
The bullets do not say tread. A reviewer describes a turned lip on the blade shoulder. Listed length: 92.5 cm. Listed weight: 998 g, which one reviewer disputes.
The Roughneck ROU68224 is a digging spade listed at 107 cm and 1.9 kg, priced at £15.59, with 4.5 from 557 amazon.co.uk reviews. It has a heat-treated blade, a Power Ring socket, a tumble-lacquered finish, a fibreglass shaft, a soft-grip D, and foot treads. Reviewers who landscape with it praise a light shaft and a blade that slices turf. Other reviewers say the neck bends on stones, the head flexes under load, or the tool is too heavy for someone with arthritis. The specification field says alloy steel while the bullets say heat-treated carbon steel. At this price it is the best-value digging spade in the set only with that split stated, not as a head the reviews agree will not bend.
Pros
Cons
Best for: You want a treaded digging spade under £16 for turf and ordinary soil, and you will take smaller bites where there are stones.
Less suitable: You are digging rubble, or you need a head that the reviews agree will not flex.
Specifications
Common questions
Is this a digging spade or a border spade?
The listing classifies it as a digging spade.
What is the blade and handle made of?
The specification says alloy steel and the bullets say heat-treated carbon steel. Handle: fibreglass.
Does it have foot treads, and how long is it?
Foot treads: yes. Listed length: 107 cm. Listed weight: 1.9 kg.
Six amazon.co.uk listings were scored on a 0–100 scale on 19 October 2026. This is not a laboratory test. Amazon evidence is 25, build and the listing are 35, review outcome is 25, and value is 15. The highest score is the top pick. The best price among the digging spades with several hundred reviews, foot treads and a stated length, after flexing-head reviews are deducted, is the best value. One of each. BS 3388:2004 applies to these tools; none of these listings is scored as having passed it.
Amazon evidence
25%Star rating on amazon.co.uk, then a deduction when the count is small. A 4.7 from 108 reviews does not outrank a 4.6 from 1,426.
Build and listing
35%A solid-forged or reinforced socket, stated foot treads, and a length and weight that can belong to a hand tool score higher. A carbon-fibre bullet that clashes with a carbon-steel specification is deducted. A dimension line of many metres and a weight line of a few hundred grams are not scored as the tool.
Review outcome
25%Praise for roots, clay, turf, or a session you can finish scores higher than a file that repeats a snapped shaft, a bent face, or a neck that flexes.
Value
15%Shelf price in GBP against a spade a UK review can use for the job in the title. The lowest price does not win this block when the tool is a border spade or the listing contradicts itself.
The six spades on this page are the amazon.co.uk listings kept for this comparison, not every spade on sale in the UK. Prices are the shelf figures captured for those listings, in GBP. A star average on its own is not the top pick. The KKTECH is 4.7 from 108 reviews and scores 42, while the JCB is 4.6 from 121 and scores 80, because the socket, the weight and the review outcomes count. Use the criteria below before you treat a low price as the best value.
A garden spade is a flat-bladed hand tool. You use it to cut turf, turn soil and dig holes. In UK shops the two everyday sizes are a digging spade and a smaller border spade. A digging spade has the wider flat blade for beds, shrub holes and lawn edges. A border spade is the same idea with a narrower blade, so it fits between plants and moves less soil per cut. Pointed and transplanting spades exist in UK tool tests. They are not in this six-listing set.
A spade cuts undisturbed ground with a flat blade. A shovel scoops loose material. If the blade is a scoop, the word spade in the title has not changed the job.
A dimension line of many metres, or a weight of a few hundred grams, is not the spade in your hands. Ignore those lines. Use a length around a metre and a weight around 2 kg only when the listing can belong to a hand tool.
Reviews on the stainless 4450DS repeat a snap where the wooden shaft enters the socket. Carbon steel rusts if you store it wet. Clean and dry a carbon head. Do not use a border spade as a site tool in dense mud.
The socket and the blade come before the word professional in a title. A solid-forged head, thicker at the socket, is what the JCB listing states. A long tight joint is the next pattern: the 4450DS is double riveted, and the Roughneck states a Power Ring socket. Reviews in this set describe snaps at the socket, a thin blade on heavy work, a face that bent in dense mud, and a neck that flexes on stones. Carbon steel is the tougher pattern if you clean and dry it.
A shaft that forces a stoop loads your back, so length and weight are buying facts. Credible listed lengths in this set are 98 cm on the JCB, 102 cm on the 4450DS, 92.5 cm on the Draper, 102 cm on the KKTECH and 107 cm on the Roughneck. Listed weights you can use are 2.4 kg on the JCB, 2.08 kg on the Elements, 998 g on the Draper, which one reviewer disputes, and 1.9 kg on the Roughneck. A dimension line of many metres, and a weight line of a few hundred grams, are not the tool.
Three typical situations, each with a recommendation from this comparison.
You want one digging spade for beds you already turn. Stainless if you will not oil the blade, carbon if you will clean and dry it. The Spear & Jackson 4450DS is the mirror-polished stainless head in this set, at about £24.20, and the wooden shaft is the part reviews say snaps if you lever it.
An allotment or a plot with clay and stones wants a forged or thick carbon head and a tread, and smaller bites rather than a bigger blade of wet soil. The JCB JCBDS01 is the solid-forged digging spade here, listed at 2.4 kg, which reviewers also call heavy for light work.
A shorter gardener, or a bed that is already planted, wants the narrower blade. The Draper 88792 is the border spade in this set. It moves less soil per cut. Some reviewers bend the face in dense mud, so it is a poor site tool.
In this set the top pick is the JCB JCBDS01 at about £29.99. It scores 80 for a solid-forged carbon head, integrated foot treads, a listed length of 98 cm and a listed weight of 2.4 kg, with 4.6 from 121 reviews that praise roots and a joint that does not flex. It is heavy for light work, and one review reports a blade that bent on first use. The best value is the Roughneck ROU68224 at about £15.59. It scores 76, with foot treads, a Power Ring socket, 107 cm and 1.9 kg, and 4.5 from 557 reviews. Reviewers praise it for slicing turf. Other reviews say the neck bends on stones and the head flexes. The other four spades have no award. None of these scores is a laboratory test.
Roughneck ROU68224 digging spade
Best value: about £15.59 for a treaded digging spade with a stated length, after flexing-head reviews are already deducted.
Editorial
Peter F. is the editor for DIY & tools at productscompared.co.uk. Comparisons in this category are checked against amazon.co.uk listings, review evidence and public UK sources.
Guides on what to look for, how to use a product, and common mistakes.
Sources from the research digest. Last checked on 19 October 2026.
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy through these links we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Links go to amazon.co.uk with the tag pcuk26-21. Prices and review counts are the shelf figures captured for these listings, not a lab test.
