The best Hole spades, compared.
Top pick: Spear & Jackson 2154HK draining shovel Best value: Spear & Jackson 2154HK draining shovel – The same 4.7, from 2,403 reviews, at about £16.20, if you can manage 2.79 kg and a handle stated at 711 mm. Updated October 2026.
A hole spade is a narrow manual tool for slots and post holes, not a border spade and not a full digging spade. A drain or grafting spade cuts a narrow hole or trench. A clamshell lifts spoil once the ground is loose. People buy them for fence and gate posts, short pipe or cable channels, and the odd deep planting hole. Type, joint and weight are in the [hole spade buying guide](/hub/digging-tools/hole-spade/sub/hole-spade-buying-guide). Nine listings are compared from amazon.co.uk data and public UK sources.
A hole spade is a narrow manual tool for slots and post holes, not a border spade and not a full digging spade. A drain or grafting spade cuts a narrow hole or trench. A clamshell lifts spoil once the ground is loose.
32 products checked · 58 hrs invested · +18,600 readers
Swipe for more
1-2 of 9
Personal buying guide
Question 1 of 2
What is the tool doing?
The Spear & Jackson 2154HK is a forged carbon and manganese draining shovel listed at £16.20, rated 4.7 from 2,403 amazon.co.uk reviews, and weighing 2.79 kg. UK reviewers use the sharp blade for fence-post holes, including in clay, and some say it cuts roots, brick and stone. The listing states a 711 mm tubular steel shaft, a rotary-welded contoured grip and an epoxy coat meant to reduce soil stick and rust. A foot tread is not in the spec block, so you are driving a head that does not advertise a standing step. Several reviewers call it heavy after a long session, and at least one wanted a longer handle than the stated 711 mm. One UK review says the blade bent and marked a router sole plate. At this price and review volume it is the best-value drain shovel in the set, if you can live with 2.79 kg beside a lighter fibreglass shaft.
Pros
Cons
Best for: You want a low-priced forged drain shovel for narrow fence-post holes and trenches, and you can manage 2.79 kg.
Less suitable: You need a stated foot tread, a longer shaft than 711 mm, or a lighter tool for a long session.
Specifications
Common questions
Is the head steel?
The listing says a fully forged head of high-strength carbon/manganese steel. Blade material is given as alloy steel and material type as carbon steel.
Does the listing state a foot tread?
No. Grip type is contoured. A foot tread is not in the raw spec block.
Do reviewers use it for fence posts?
Yes. Several UK reviews describe fence-post holes, including in clay.
The Roughneck ROU68238 is a sharpened carbon-steel drain and post-hole shovel listed at £21.54, rated 4.7 from 1,336 amazon.co.uk reviews, and weighing 1.98 kg. The title states 1070 mm overall, with a fibreglass shaft, a D-grip, foot treads and a power-ring socket. Reviewers use the blade for fence posts and narrow holes, including clay and roots, and one review mentions old concrete and brick plus holes about 600 mm deep. They prefer it where a full-width spade would open too wide a hole, and they call the fibreglass handle lighter and comfortable. One reviewer says the collar is a little wide and catches the sides of a deeper hole. The sampled UK reviews do not repeat a bend or a snap. It is the top pick here for a drain-and-post-hole shovel, though it is not a one-piece forged head if you are driving into hardcore all day.
Pros
Cons
Best for: You want a lighter drain and post-hole shovel with foot treads for narrow trenches, cables and fence posts.
Less suitable: You need a forged one-piece head for hardcore, or the collar will foul a very deep slot.
Specifications
Common questions
Can it dig post holes?
The title says drainage and post hole shovel. UK reviews describe fence-post holes dug with it.
What is the handle?
Fibreglass, with a D-grip. The title states 1070 mm overall.
Are there foot treads?
Yes. The listing says foot treads to reduce slippage.
The Roughneck 68-250 is a traditional-pattern clamshell listed at £39.99, rated 4.7 from 354 amazon.co.uk reviews, with 1.5 m fibreglass handles and a listing weight of 5.2 kg. The bullets cite knuckle-saving grips, alloy-steel blades and a forward turn step, and the item type is Posthole Digger even though the style name says Multi-Purpose Shovel/Spade Hybrid. Reviewers use it to lift spoil once the ground is loose, including stones and brick in some accounts, and they describe decking and fence holes about 40–90 cm deep. They also say the lift is tiring at 5.2 kg, and that you still want a bar or a drainage shovel for rocks and unbroken clay. Handles can arrive misaligned so the knuckle guards do not line up, and one review mentions yellow blade labels that are hard to remove. It is a heavy lifter for deep holes, not the tool that should break dry clay by itself.
Pros
Cons
Best for: You want a heavy clamshell to lift spoil from deep fence or decking holes after the ground is broken.
Less suitable: You need a light tool, a cutter for dry clay, or you cannot check handle alignment on delivery.
Specifications
Common questions
Is this a clamshell or a single shovel?
Item type is Posthole Digger. Reviews describe two blades and knuckle guards. The style name says Multi-Purpose Shovel/Spade Hybrid.
How heavy is it?
The listing says 5.2 kg. Reviewers call the lift hard work.
Will it cut hard clay alone?
Several reviews say you still need a bar, auger, or drainage shovel, and that this tool pulls loosened soil out.
The Neilsen CT1148 is a clamshell post-hole digger listed at £28.99, rated 4.6 from 591 amazon.co.uk reviews, with 1510 mm fibreglass handles, rubber grips, carbon-steel blades and a listing weight of 3.32 kg. The listing says it is not foldable. Reviewers say fence-post holes are easier than with a spade alone, and they report clay, rubble and roots, with the long handles reducing how far you bend. One reviewer even cleaned driveway drain traps with it. The same reviews say it twists or warps on stones and small roots, or if you try to rotate it, and some people loosen the soil with a fork or an auger first. One review mentions coating damage on arrival. At 3.32 kg it is lighter than the 5.2 kg Roughneck clamshell, and it still does not cut unbroken ground on its own.
Pros
Cons
Best for: You want a mid-price fibreglass clamshell to lift spoil from fence and gate holes once the ground is loose.
Less suitable: You expect it to break hard clay or rock by twisting, or you need a tool that folds.
Specifications
Common questions
What are the handles?
Fibreglass, with rubber grips. Stated length 1510 mm. Listing weight 3.32 kg.
Is it only for soft soil?
Reviews include dense clay and rubble. Others say it twists on stones and roots.
Does it fold?
The listing says Is Foldable: No.
The Spear & Jackson PHD-WH is an ash-handled clamshell listed at £46.15, rated 4.5 from 1,049 amazon.co.uk reviews, with a hardened steel oval mouth and a listing weight of 4.13 kg. Item length is 146.5 cm, and a separate handle length is not stated. Reviewers say it lifts soil from post holes more easily than a spade, and some find the weight helps the thrust, with holes around 600–900 mm once the ground is already loose. They also use it where an auger cannot turn, and they call the weatherproofed ash long-lasting if you look after it. The same reviews say it is heavy on the back and shoulders, poor at cutting unbroken hard ground, and that dry soil falls out of the blades. Stones, brick and clay still slow it down. It is a well-reviewed lifter at the top of this price band, and it still needs another tool to break dry or stony soil first.
Pros
Cons
Best for: You want a wooden-handled clamshell with a large review count to lift spoil from deep post holes.
Less suitable: You need the tool that breaks dry clay, or you want to avoid a 4.13 kg lift on a long run.
Specifications
Common questions
What are the handles?
Ash wood, described as weatherproofed hardwood. Grip type is contoured wood.
Can it cut hard clay by itself?
Reviewers say it lifts soil that is already broken. Hard, stony or dry ground needs another tool first, and dry soil falls out.
How heavy is it?
The listing says 4.13 kg.
The JCB Drain Master JCBDM01 is a solid-forged grafting spade listed at £36.99, rated 4.5 from 103 amazon.co.uk reviews, and weighing 2.78 kg. The title states a tapered blade of 400 x 180/110 mm, and a bullet calls it a long narrow 16 inch blade, with integrated foot treads, a sharpened edge and an all-steel handle on a single-piece forged head. Reviewers use the narrow blade in stony clay where a wider spade struggled, and they mention trenches, hardcore, roots and a bamboo-barrier trench, with less spoil than a full-width spade. Some lighter or older reviewers call it heavy. One tree-planting review says it did not make compacted clay easy, and one UK review reports a failure on first use. The country of origin on the listing is India. It is the forged graft in this set when you want a one-piece head and a stated tread, at a higher price than the two 4.7 drain shovels.
Pros
Cons
Best for: You want a forged Newcastle-style graft with foot treads for narrow holes in stony clay.
Less suitable: You want the lowest price, or you need a lighter shaft for a long session in compacted clay.
Specifications
Common questions
Is the head one piece?
The listing says a single-piece solid forged head and a thicker forged socket.
Are there foot treads?
Yes. Integrated foot treads are in the bullets.
What blade size is stated?
The title says 400 x 180/110 mm. A bullet says a long narrow 16 inch tapered blade.
The JCB JCBFG01 is a fencing drain and grafting spade listed at £44.99, rated 4.4 from 17 amazon.co.uk reviews, with a stated 260 mm carbon-steel blade and a listing weight of 3.1 kg. The bullets aim it at fence lines, drainage, narrow trenches and cable routes, with a long handle and a tubular steel grip, and the listing says it is not foldable. A numeric handle length is not stated. The item dimensions include a 1 cm figure that the listing does not explain. Four UK review texts are in the file: one person dug solid clay, another called it solid for post holes in clay, and none of those four describes a break or a bend. That is a short sample beside drain shovels with thousands of reviews, at the highest blade price in this set. It suits a narrow fence line if you accept how little owner evidence there is.
Pros
Cons
Best for: You want a narrow fencing drain spade for a fence line and you can accept a 17-review listing.
Less suitable: You want a large review sample, a stated foot tread, or a lower price for the same narrow-hole job.
Specifications
Common questions
What blade length is stated?
260 mm, in the title and the bullets.
Does it fold?
The listing says Is Foldable: No.
Do the UK reviews in the saved listing describe a break?
No. Four UK reviews are in the file. None describes a break or a bend.
The Jardineer 5005-2 is a sectional serrated root shovel listed at £29.99, rated 4.1 from 36 amazon.co.uk reviews, with a stated weight of 1.2 kg and a 26 cm heat-treated V blade. The listing says 115 cm after assembly, and a bullet also says 45 inches, with a T-handle, a foot platform and assembly tools in the box. Reviewers say the pointed blade cuts some bramble and hedge roots, and that the supplied spanners make the bolted shaft straightforward to put together. The same small sample says the joints still wobble when the bolts are tight, and some people returned it as weaker than a one-piece shaft. Individual reviews say it did not cut bamboo or light lawn roots, and one person lost the sheath. At 1.2 kg it is light beside a forged graft, and the bolted sections are the limit on a hard day. Thirty-six reviews is a thin record next to the drain shovels with thousands.
Pros
Cons
Best for: You want a light serrated blade for roots and compacted beds, and you will keep the bolts tight.
Less suitable: You need a one-piece shaft for clay fence posts, or you expect it to cut bamboo.
Specifications
Common questions
Does it need assembly?
Yes. It arrives in sections and is bolted together. Reviews mention 13 mm and 14 mm spanners in the box.
Do the joints stay tight?
Some reviews say it feels sturdy once tight. Others say the joints still wobble.
Is the blade serrated?
Yes. The listing says side serrations and a heat-treated V blade. Stated blade length is 26 cm.
The OLLIDOT CTJ is a screw-together clamshell listed at £29.99, rated 3.8 from 29 amazon.co.uk reviews, with a stated length of 139 cm and a listing weight of 3.79 kg. The title length and the item dimensions of 43.5 x 25 x 11 cm do not match, so the shorter figure may be the packed size. Some reviewers dug several holes around 60 cm and liked that the handles come apart for the car. Others say it is not heavy duty, and the work is still hard when it holds together. Reports in the sample include coming apart while digging, bending on first use with loose handles, and breaking on the first hole. The blades are described only as metal, with no steel grade in the spec block. It is a light-job lifter if the screws stay tight, and it is a poor bet for a day of clay.
Pros
Cons
Best for: You need a detachable lifter for a few light holes and you can check the screws stay tight.
Less suitable: You are starting a clay or rubble run, or you need a tool that reviewers treat as heavy duty.
Specifications
Common questions
Does it come apart?
Yes. The listing says it is detachable, with screw connections, for transport.
Is it for a day of heavy clay?
UK reviews split. A few light jobs are described as fine. Several say it bent, loosened, or came apart.
How long is it?
The title says 139 cm. Item dimensions are 43.5 x 25 x 11 cm, which may be the packed size.
Nine amazon.co.uk listings were scored from the product data kept for this comparison: a drain or graft blade, a serrated root shovel, and clamshell post-hole diggers. This is not a laboratory test. A star row is the amazon.co.uk figure. A steel grade, a tread or a length is used only when the listing states it. The five weights below sum to 100. The top pick is the Roughneck drainage and post hole shovel. The best value is the Spear & Jackson 2154HK.
Job shape
25%A drain or graft blade cuts a narrow hole or trench. A clamshell lifts spoil once the ground is loose. A digging spade, a border spade or a mini shovel is a different tool.
Ground
20%Hard clay and stone need a narrow forged blade, and usually a bar. Dry sand falls out of clamshell jaws. A serrated edge is for roots, not rubble.
Joint
20%A forged head or a reinforced socket beats a bolted three-piece shaft if you will lever. Foot treads matter under a boot.
Mass
15%Fibreglass drain spades here sit near 2 kg. Clamshells sit around 3.3–5.2 kg before soil. A longer handle helps in a deep hole and costs you on the lift.
Evidence
20%Separate blade tools from clamshells before you read the stars. A 4.7 from more than a thousand reviews is not a 4.4 from 17.
Match the tool to the hole before you compare the shelf price. A drain or graft blade cuts. A clamshell lifts spoil that is already loose. Prices on the nine amazon.co.uk listings run from about £16.20 to about £46.15. Separate those two jobs before you read the stars. A 4.7 from more than a thousand reviews is not a 4.4 from 17.
A hole spade, for a UK shopper, is a narrow manual tool for slots and post holes. It is not a border spade and not a full digging spade. The two tools that do the job are a drain or grafting spade, which cuts a narrow hole or trench, and a clamshell post-hole digger, which lifts spoil once the ground is loose. People buy them for fence and gate posts, short pipe or cable channels, and the odd deep planting hole.
A hole spade is a narrow tool. A digging spade, a border spade or a mini shovel opens a different hole. B&Q describes a drain spade as slimmer than a digging spade. If the slot only needs to take a post, a cable or a short pipe, a full-width blade moves spoil you then have to put back.
A clamshell lifts spoil once the ground is loose. Conservation Handbooks says not to make the hole with one except in very soft soil, sand or peat. Twisting it on a stone is how these tools warp. Hard clay and stone need a narrow forged blade, and usually a bar, first. Dry sand falls out of the jaws.
A forged head or a reinforced socket beats a bolted three-piece shaft if you will lever. The Jardineer arrives in sections, and reviews say the joints still wobble when the bolts are tight. A serrated edge is for roots, not rubble. Buy a border spade only if that is the job.
A drain or graft blade cuts a narrow hole or trench. A clamshell lifts soil that is already loose. A digging spade, a border spade or a mini shovel is a different tool, and a wide cone dug with a garden spade is the usual mistake. B&Q describes a drain spade as slimmer than a digging spade. A graft, or Newcastle-pattern drainer, is the heavier narrow blade, often with foot treads, for clay and a deep cut.
A forged head or a reinforced socket beats a bolted three-piece shaft if you will lever. Foot treads matter under a boot. The Roughneck drain shovel and the JCB Drain Master state treads. The Spear & Jackson 2154HK does not. The Jardineer states a foot platform, and reviews say the bolted joints still wobble. Fibreglass drain spades in this set sit near 2 kg: the Roughneck is 1.98 kg and the Spear & Jackson tubular shovel is 2.79 kg. Clamshells sit around 3.3–5.2 kg before soil.
Three typical situations, each with a recommendation from this comparison.
You are setting a few fence or gate posts and you need a narrow blade, often with a clamshell afterwards to lift the spoil. The Roughneck drainage and post hole shovel is about £21.54, rated 4.7 from 1,336 reviews, at 1.98 kg with foot treads. Reviewers use it for fence-post holes, including in clay.
You are cutting a short trench for a pipe or a cable, after you have scanned for services, and you want treads and a strong narrow blade. The JCB Drain Master is a solid-forged graft at about £36.99, with foot treads and a tapered blade stated at 400 x 180/110 mm. Reviewers use it in stony clay.
You want the lowest price in this set for a forged drain shovel and you can manage 2.79 kg. The Spear & Jackson 2154HK is about £16.20, rated 4.7 from 2,403 reviews. A foot tread is not stated. A long clay run is a hire job, not a reason to buy a heavier clamshell and force it.
The top pick is the Roughneck drainage and post hole shovel at about £21.54. It weighs 1.98 kg, with a fibreglass shaft, a D-grip, foot treads and a sharpened carbon-steel blade, rated 4.7 from 1,336 amazon.co.uk reviews. Reviewers use it for fence posts and narrow holes. The collar can catch in a deeper slot, and it is not a one-piece forged head. The best value is the Spear & Jackson 2154HK at about £16.20, also 4.7, from 2,403 reviews, with a forged head at 2.79 kg and no stated foot tread. Skip both if you only need a clamshell to lift spoil.
Spear & Jackson 2154HK draining shovel
The same 4.7, from 2,403 reviews, at about £16.20, if you can manage 2.79 kg and a handle stated at 711 mm.
Editorial
Peter F. is the editor for DIY & tools at productscompared.co.uk. Comparisons in this category are checked against amazon.co.uk listings, review evidence and public UK sources.
Guides on what to look for, how to use a product, and common mistakes.
Public UK sources from the research digest. Prices, stars and review counts are the amazon.co.uk listing lines used in this comparison. We did not run a lab test.
This page contains affiliate links to amazon.co.uk with the tag pcuk26-21. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Prices, stars and review counts are the amazon.co.uk listing lines used in this comparison. We did not run a lab test.
