Independent comparisons. We may earn from shop links. More info

Smoking dust for cheese

Updated: 23 October 2026

A block of mature cheddar from the supermarket tastes flat, the day is cool, and you want smoke on the cheese rather than a soft puddle on the rack. Smoking dust for cheese is a cold flavouring, not a cook. The dust has to stay below the cheese, the smoke has to stay thin, and the block needs a night in the fridge before you decide whether it worked. Published UK methods and the listing notes in our [smoking dust comparison](/hub/grill-accessories/smoking-dust) were checked on 20 October 2026. This is not a lab test, and a qualifying Amazon purchase can earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.

A block of mature cheddar from the supermarket tastes flat, the day is cool, and you want smoke on the cheese rather than a soft puddle on the rack. Smoking dust for cheese is a cold flavouring, not a cook.

Our top picks

Stove Wizard Stove Wizard oak, 2 x 1.5 L

Best overall

Stove Wizard Stove Wizard oak, 2 x 1.5 L
7.4/10about £17.99
View offer
J Major J Major acacia, 500 g

Best value

J Major J Major acacia, 500 g
6.8/10about £9.50
View offer
Stove Wizard Stove Wizard cherry, 2 x 1.5 L

Alternative

Stove Wizard Stove Wizard cherry, 2 x 1.5 L
6.0/10about £17.99
View offer
On this page
  1. 1.Which cheese is worth a first try
  2. 2.Keep it cool and keep a gap
  3. 3.How long, then the fridge
  4. 4.Which dust, lightly
  5. 5.If the cheese softens

Which cheese is worth a first try

Great British Chefs names cheddar, Red Leicester, Double Gloucester, Wensleydale, Cheshire and Lancashire for a cold smoke. A 500 g piece of mature cheddar, cut so the smoke can reach more than one face, is the ProQ starting point if that is what you already have. Soft cheese is where the sources split. Great British Chefs is wary of Stilton and other blues, and also reports a camembert that took smoke. ProQ says to smoke soft cheeses whole. A first session is kinder on a hard cheese you can cube. A whole camembert is a later try, on a day as cool as the method you are copying.

Keep it cool and keep a gap

ProQ's cheese method says not to start if the day is above 30°C, and to set the generator at least 30 cm below the rack. Great British Chefs uses a tin of sawdust with no flame, and says the cheese must not sit over heat above 15°C. Those are two limits for two setups, not an average. A generator afternoon at 22°C is inside ProQ's start rule and outside the tin method's warning. Match the number to the kit you own. If the block slumps, the chamber was too warm or the rack was too close. Take it out and chill it. ProQ notes that trapped smoke tastes like creosote. You want a thin haze you can see through. Lighting the dust is on how to use smoking dust.
Stove Wizard Stove Wizard oak, 2 x 1.5 L

Testsieger

Stove Wizard Stove Wizard oak, 2 x 1.5 L
7.4/10about £17.99
View offer

How long, then the fridge

The clocks do not agree, because the kits do not agree. ProQ cold-smokes about 500 g of mature cheddar, in pieces of about 2.5 cm, for 2–3 hours, then wraps it and rests it overnight. Great British Chefs keeps the tin method to 30–60 minutes. Pro Smoke BBQ often puts cheese at 2–4 hours and says to stay under 30°C. Do not blend those into one clock nobody published. On a maze, ProQ's 2–3 hours matches that kit. On an unlit tin, the shorter time and the 15°C warning belong together. Stop if the smoke tastes harsh or the cheese softens. Then wrap it and leave it in the fridge overnight. Tasting it five minutes later tells you about the surface, not the block.

Which dust, lightly

ProQ suggests oak for that cheddar, and also names maple and apple. Hickory is easy to overdo on a food that sits in smoke for hours. In this comparison the hickory copy aims at ribs and brisket, not a first cheddar. Cherry listings name cheese, and J Major's acacia bullets name cheese as well. Those are listing lines, not a cheese test. A cherry or acacia bag is a mild option beside oak if the title and the model number agree, which the smoking dust buying guide checks. Whiskey-titled dust here does not match its model number. Bitter cheese is usually too much smoke, too long, or smoke that sat trapped.

If the cheese softens

Take it out and refrigerate it. Cold smoking dust is there for flavour. If the chamber is hot enough to soften cheddar, you have left cold smoking. Do not push on with more time. Meats that need a proper cook, including bacon, still need that cook afterwards. This page is not a method for ready-to-eat cold-smoked fish.

Common questions

What temperature melts cheese?
ProQ says not to start a generator cheese smoke above 30°C. Great British Chefs says cheese in their tin method must not sit over heat above 15°C. Neither figure is a lab melting point for every cheddar. If the block softens, the box was too warm for the method you chose. Chill it and do not push on.
How far above the generator should the rack sit?
ProQ says at least 30 cm below the cheese. That gap is part of keeping the smoke cool and stopping the dust from heating the rack directly. A tin method is a different layout, so do not paste the 30 cm rule onto a setup that has no generator. Closer than the maker allows is how a cool day still melts the surface.
Do I rest it in the fridge, and for how long?
Yes. ProQ says wrap it and rest overnight or longer. The smoke taste settles in that time. Tasting it straight off the rack mostly tells you about the outside. If it is harsh after a night, the next batch wants less time or thinner smoke, not a stronger wood.
Can I smoke a whole camembert?
ProQ says soft cheeses should be smoked whole. Great British Chefs is cautious about Stilton and blue cheese and also describes a camembert that worked. Treat a whole soft cheese as a second try, on a cool day, with a mild dust. A first session is kinder on a hard British cheese you can cut.
Is this the same method as smoked salmon?
No. This page is a cool smoke for hard cheese. It is not advice to eat ready-to-eat cold-smoked fish, and it is not a cure. Fish has its own safety rules. Do not copy the cheese times onto raw fish and treat the result as finished food.

Related pages

Smoking dust vs wood chips

Smoking dust

Best smoking dust UK: match the wood, skip the stars

Smoking dust buying guide: size, wood, then the price

How to use smoking dust: dry it, fill, then stay out

Sources

Public UK sources used for cold smoke, Listeria, and carbon monoxide. Listing prices, stars, and review counts are the amazon.co.uk lines in this comparison.

  1. FSA — cold-smoked fish advice, 27 July 2023 (retrieved 22.10.2026)
  2. FSA — Listeria in ready-to-eat smoked fish (retrieved 22.10.2026)
  3. ProQ — cold smoking (retrieved 22.10.2026)
  4. ProQ — cold smoke generator (retrieved 22.10.2026)
  5. ProQ — smoking woods (retrieved 22.10.2026)
  6. Hot Smoked — oak smoking dust (retrieved 22.10.2026)
  7. London Fire Brigade — carbon monoxide (retrieved 22.10.2026)
  8. Down The Cove — which wood chips (retrieved 22.10.2026)