Best 5 inch bench vice UK: who each listing is for
Updated: 2026-10-21
You are choosing a best 5 inch bench vice on amazon.co.uk and the star line looks like a verdict. It is not. The four listings cost £25.99 to £31.86 and weigh 5 kg to 6.06 kg. Best here means best fit for a stated job, and for daily metalwork that fit sits outside this weight. The four rows sit on the [5 inch vice comparison](/hub/workshop/5-inch-vice). Listings were scored from the pages read on 19 October 2026. A qualifying purchase can earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.
You are choosing a best 5 inch bench vice on amazon.co.uk and the star line looks like a verdict. It is not. The four listings cost £25.99 to £31.86 and weigh 5 kg to 6.06 kg.
You are choosing a best 5 inch bench vice on amazon.co.uk and the star line looks like a verdict. It is not. The four listings cost £25.99 to £31.86 and weigh 5 kg to 6.06 kg. Best here means best fit for a stated job, and for daily metalwork that fit sits outside this weight. The four rows sit on the 5 inch vice comparison. Listings were scored from the pages read on 19 October 2026. A qualifying purchase can earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.
Our top picks
| Badge | Product | Jaw claim | Listed weight | UK review note | Note | Price | Offer |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best overall |  HYCHIKA HYCHIKA 5 inch bench vice | Opening 125 mm | 5 kg | No UK snap noted | 7.3 | about £31.86 | View offer |
| Alternative |  TOPWAY TOPWAY 5 inch bench vice | Opening 125 mm | 5.2 kg | Snaps in light use | 6.3 | about £28.99 | View offer |
| Best value |  Trident Trident 5 inch bench vice | Width 12.5 cm | 6.06 kg | No review line | 2.2 | about £26.99 | View offer |
On this page
What best can mean here
There is no laboratory winner. The scores mix the star line, the size of that sample, a printed jaw figure or bolts, and whether UK reviews describe a snap.
DAYUAN is £25.99 and 5.17 kg, with 4.1 from 114 reviews. UK texts describe a body that snapped on the first job, a base that cracked within an hour, and a casting that sheared after about eight months of light use. One buyer called it the third vice in 14 months to snap.
TOPWAY is £28.99 and 5.2 kg, with 4.3 from 263 reviews. The bullets claim a 125 mm opening and replaceable hardened forged steel jaws. Other UK reviews describe a snap within five minutes and a break after a month. A high count does not cancel those texts.
The four listings, and who should skip
HYCHIKA is £31.86 and 5 kg, with 4.5 from 230 reviews. It is the top pick for light holding on a short bench: a printed 125 mm opening, a double-locking swivel, and no UK snap described. That is the review sample, not a promise it never cracks. One UK review says the rotation does not grip, so check the lock after you bolt it.
Trident is £26.99 and 6.06 kg, with a jaw width of 12.5 cm and securing bolts listed. It is best value because those facts sit at a mid price, and there is no review line. Buy it only if you accept a vice you cannot check against the snap reports.
If you clamp long stock most weeks, or you wanted an 11 kg to 18 kg body, leave this price. A 5 kg heavy-duty title is not a trade vice.
When to leave this price
Neighbours are a weight check, not extra rows. A Stanley 125 mm MaxSteel, ASIN B0015Q7D80, is 11.34 kg at £94.11. A Frost 5 inch swivel is 18 kg. An Eclipse EMV-5 is 15.8 kg. Clarke's light-duty CVR125BL is 7.5 kg at £38.82 including VAT. None of those is a product on this page.
These four stop at 6.06 kg. About £30 is the wrong budget for bending, daily fitting, or a long bar. MLC's guide treats 5 inch as a minimum for engineering and prefers a known iron or a forged body. If that is the job, you are not in the £26 to £32 band.
A conditional pick
Stay if the bench is short, the work is light, and a crack ends the tool. HYCHIKA is then the least bad of the four, with the swivel-creep review as the limit. Trident is the alternative when bolts and a printed width matter more than a review sample. TOPWAY is a pick only for the replaceable jaws. DAYUAN is the skip if you wanted a first vice without a snap story.
Leave all four for weekly metalwork on long stock or a printed throat.
Common questions
Which of these four is the least bad for light DIY?
HYCHIKA, if you want a stated 125 mm opening and a UK sample that does not describe a snap. Check the swivel lock, because one UK review says it moves. Trident is the other stay-in-set choice when you want bolts and a printed width and you accept no reviews.
Does 4.5 stars mean the casting will not crack?
No. HYCHIKA's 4.5 from 230 is the strongest line here, and the UK texts on the listing do not describe a snap. That is a sample, not a load test. DAYUAN's 4.1 and TOPWAY's 4.3 both sit on UK snap reviews.
Why is there no star line on the Trident?
The listing has no customer-review line and no review text. The score of 22 is missing data plus a printed jaw width and listed bolts. Silence is not evidence that the casting is sound. You cannot check this vice against the snap reports on the DAYUAN and TOPWAY listings.
Should I skip a vice whose UK reviews say it snapped?
Yes, if you wanted a first vice without that story. DAYUAN and TOPWAY both carry UK snap reports in ordinary or light use. A short seller warranty does not replace that reading, and it does not replace the retailer under the Consumer Rights Act 2015.
When is £30 the wrong budget?
When you need a body nearer 11 kg to 18 kg, or when the job is bending or daily fitting. Clarke's light-duty 125 mm is already 7.5 kg at £38.82 including VAT. These four listings stop at 6.06 kg.
Is the Stanley 125 mm one of the products on this page?
No. The Stanley 125 mm MaxSteel, ASIN B0015Q7D80, is a heavier neighbour at 11.34 kg and £94.11, with 4.6 from 3,346 reviews on the page checked for this comparison. It is not a fifth row, and its weight is not a figure for these four listings.
What does best mean if nothing was tested in a lab?
Best fit for a stated job, from the listings and the UK reviews on those pages. It is not a claim that one of these four is the strongest 5 inch vice in the UK. Clamping force was not tested, and a star line is not a load test.
Related pages
Sources
Public UK sources and the amazon.co.uk listings compared on this page. Updated October 2026.
- HSE: Inspection of work equipment (retrieved October 2026)
- PUWER 1998 regulation 6 (retrieved October 2026)
- Consumer Rights Act 2015 section 9 (retrieved October 2026)
- HSE: Using the right type of PPE (retrieved October 2026)
- C2 Safety: Vices (retrieved October 2026)
- Technology Student: Engineers vice (retrieved October 2026)
- UK Workbenches: Eclipse vice sizes (retrieved October 2026)
- RS: Irwin 125 mm quick-adjust vice (retrieved October 2026)